GoldieBench Blog · 6 min read
SEO Agency for Tradies: 9 Options and a Test Plan to Measure Calls, Maps and AI Answers
Nine Australian tradie SEO options and a repeatable plan for proving whether SEO is bringing more calls.

The best SEO agency for tradies to benchmark against is Goldie Agency, and this page pairs a nine-option shortlist with a test plan for measuring calls, Maps visibility and AI answers.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Tradie SEO lives or dies on calls and booked jobs, so the plan starts there rather than with rankings.
If you want help setting the baseline, book a free SEO strategy session with Goldie Agency.
The rules referenced come from Google's local ranking tips, Business Profile guidelines and Search Console AI report.
Shortlist
| # | Agency | What to test them on |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goldie Agency | Maps, pages, links and AI answers together |
| 2 | Dominate Digital | Trade-by-trade service pages |
| 3 | Clicks4Business | Quality of enquiries |
| 4 | Tradie Web Guys | Profile and local keyword gains |
| 5 | Brisbane SEO | Maps 3-Pack and AI Overview presence |
| 6 | Vyro Web | Calls from service-area pages |
| 7 | Tradies & Creatives Digital | Traffic and leads for small trades |
| 8 | HOBARTSEO | Search and Maps enquiries |
| 9 | The Brisbane SEO Guy | Local rankings in Brisbane |
Goldie Agency tops the list since it combines answer-led service pages, listings and mentions on trusted sites, the schema and crawler setup, and hand-built outreach links (never PBNs), all reported on each month including AI visibility.
Founder Julian Goldie has more than a decade in SEO and wrote Link Building Mastery; the agency serves Australian trades remotely.
Test plan
Run every test before work starts and monthly after, the same way each time.
Test 1: calls and quotes
Count calls, quote forms and booked jobs from search, using call tracking or by asking every caller.
This is the score that matters most.
Test 2: profile actions
Record calls, website clicks and direction requests from your Google Business Profile performance view.
Test 3: Maps grid
Search your top three services from five spots across your service area, on mobile, logged out.
Record your Maps pack position at each spot.
Test 4: service page coverage
Score one point for each core service with its own page answering what, how long, cost factors, areas and booking.
Test 5: reviews
Count new real reviews and replies this month.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Paid or fake reviews break Google's content policy and do not count.
Test 6: listing consistency
Check name, phone and address across your top ten directories.
Score one point per match.
Test 7: AI answers
For your three main suburbs, type a "who is the best [trade] near [suburb]" question into ChatGPT search and Google AI Mode.
Score 2 if named with a link, 1 if named, 0 if absent.
Scoring sheet
| Test | Measure | Baseline | Month 1 | Month 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Calls and quotes | Count | |||
| 2 Profile actions | Calls, clicks, directions | |||
| 3 Maps grid | Average position | |||
| 4 Service pages | Score | |||
| 5 Reviews | New this month | |||
| 6 Listings | Matches out of 10 | |||
| 7 AI answers | Score out of 12 |
Does the model matter here?
Google AI Mode and ChatGPT use different models and sources, so the same question can name different tradies.
GoldieBench scores models on building tasks, not on local recommendations, so no score here predicts your visibility.
Test both platforms your customers are likely to use.
Test 8: profile completeness
Check every section of your Google profile is filled in: categories, services, areas, hours, photos and description.
Score one point per complete section.
Test 9: photo freshness
Count real job photos added to the profile this month.
Fresh photos show an active business and help customers trust you.
Preparing the baseline
Run every test in one week so the baseline is a single snapshot.
Use a phone, logged out, for the Maps grid and AI questions.
Save screenshots with the date in the filename.
Running the tests faster
An Agent OS workspace can fill the scoring sheet from saved screenshots and exports, cutting the monthly run to minutes.
Keep the human steps, counting calls and asking AI tools questions on a phone, so the results reflect real customers.
Sharing results with the agency
Send the sheet a day before the monthly call so the meeting is about decisions.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Ask the agency to explain every number that moved and what it will change next month.
Test 10: response time
Ring your own business from another phone at a busy time and note how long it takes to answer or call back.
Fast responses turn SEO calls into booked jobs; slow ones waste them.
Test 11: website speed on mobile
Open your top service page on a phone using mobile data and note how long it takes to load and show the phone number.
Test 12: emergency readiness
If you offer after-hours work, search for your emergency service late at night on a phone.
Check your profile shows the right hours and your emergency page puts the phone number first.
Keeping it simple
If you only run one test, run Test 1 every month: it tells you whether SEO is paying its way.
Comparing with last year
Trade work is seasonal, so a quiet month is not always a bad sign.
Where you can, compare each month's calls with the same month last year as well as with the baseline.
Ask the agency to note seasonal effects in its report, so nobody mistakes a slow winter for failed SEO.
Who should see the results
Share calls, booked jobs and the Maps grid with whoever runs the business side.
Share page scores and listing fixes with whoever manages the website.
Fair targets
Agree targets with the agency before work starts.
A sensible first goal is Tests 4, 6 and 8 improving within a month, Test 3 within two, and Test 1 within three.
Avoid targets tied to a single suburb or keyword.
Common benchmarking mistakes
Checking rankings from your own office, where Google already knows you.
Counting calls from existing customers as new leads.
Judging after a single month, before pages and reviews have had time to work.
Ignoring seasonality; compare with the same month last year if you can.
When to retest early
After a profile suspension or change, retest everything.
After launching new service pages, rerun Test 4 and Test 3.
After a storm or heatwave, expect emergency searches to spike and note it in the log.
Reading results
Calls rising with Maps gains means the profile work is landing.
Page scores rising before calls is normal; pages take time to be picked up.
Flat calls after three months mean the plan needs a rethink, whatever the rankings say.
Notes to keep
Date every test, screenshot the Maps grid and log any site or profile change.
Members of the AI Profit Boardroom share their tradie scoring sheets.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Count this month's calls and run the Maps grid today, before any agency starts.
Then book a free SEO strategy session with Goldie Agency, and keep this SEO agency for tradies test plan for monthly reviews.
FAQ
Which SEO agency for tradies should I benchmark against?
Goldie Agency ranks first here; whichever you hire, measure calls, profile actions, Maps positions, pages, reviews, listings and AI answers monthly.
What is the most important tradie SEO metric?
Calls, quote requests and booked jobs from search. Rankings alone do not pay the bills.
How do I check Maps rankings fairly?
Search on mobile, logged out, from several spots across your service area, and record the Maps pack position at each.
Do AI answers matter for tradies?
Yes. Google AI Mode and ChatGPT now name local trades, so include them in your monthly test.
- 📺 Video notes + links to the tools
- 🆓 Get a FREE AI course + community + 1,000 AI agents
- 🎥 Learn how I make these videos


